this post was submitted on 06 Apr 2024
132 points (88.8% liked)

Technology

59091 readers
4107 users here now

This is a most excellent place for technology news and articles.


Our Rules


  1. Follow the lemmy.world rules.
  2. Only tech related content.
  3. Be excellent to each another!
  4. Mod approved content bots can post up to 10 articles per day.
  5. Threads asking for personal tech support may be deleted.
  6. Politics threads may be removed.
  7. No memes allowed as posts, OK to post as comments.
  8. Only approved bots from the list below, to ask if your bot can be added please contact us.
  9. Check for duplicates before posting, duplicates may be removed

Approved Bots


founded 1 year ago
MODERATORS
 

Really just curious what folks out there deem valuable enough to give money for monthly or annually. As a software engineer I have quite a few that keep me productive and I'll list a few:

  • ChatGPT
  • Perplexity
  • Obsidian Sync
  • YouTube Premium
you are viewing a single comment's thread
view the rest of the comments
[–] [email protected] 5 points 7 months ago (2 children)

Nebula

Do you like it? There's only like 10 creators I watch on YouTube who are there, and I'm not sure if I'll be able to find replacements. If I pay for Nebula, I'd rather ditch YouTube entirely.

And yeah, I use Grayjay and I'm about ready to buy it. I love the new Twitch integration, and some are on Odyssey, so that's cool. The app seems to use a lot more resources than NewPipe, and it's missing a few NewPipe features I really like (seeing playlists is the biggest one), but overall it's pretty good. If it was FOSS I'd buy it today, I'm just hesitating because there's just too many tradeoffs.

[–] [email protected] 9 points 7 months ago (2 children)

I'm a big fan of Nebula, though the calculus is a bit different because there a re probably upwards of 20 creators that I already watched from YouTube on there (even higher if you count the channels rather than the creators), plus a few more that I rediscovered, plus a fair few that I discovered for the first time on Nebula.

The biggest draw is probably the Nebula exclusives. Lindsay Ellis has put out 6 excellent videos since she withdrew from YouTube for good. Many other creators do bonus content for their regular videos, as well as a growing library of exclusive standalone productions. If you tell me which of their creators interest you, I could check and let you know how much bonus content you'd get from them.

But honestly, for me, the best thing is that it's sort of like a Super-Patreon. Sure, I could sign up to all of those creators' Patreons, and that would support them the most, but then I'd be paying well over $100 per month. Instead, with Nebula's annual plan, it's just $30 per year, and still supports them significantly more than a YouTube view, even one on Premium (which is itself significantly better than an ad view).

[–] [email protected] 7 points 7 months ago (2 children)

Honestly, I don't care about bonus content, I just want the content I have on YouTube elsewhere without ads and tracking, and I'm happy to pay for it.

The only ones I'm interested in are:

  • Not Just Bikes
  • Half as Interesting

I looked through the rest, and I honestly haven't heard of any of them. I don't watch a ton of YouTube, but I do follow a few channels. Here are some of my favorites, by category:

Tech news:

  • Level1Techs
  • Louis Rossmann - on Odysee
  • Gamer's Nexus
  • Optimum Tech
  • Digital Foundry
  • The Phawx

Privacy/advocacy:

  • Audit the Audit
  • Mental Outlaw
  • NBTV - Naomi Brockwell

Math/science:

  • Stand Up Maths
  • Psyshow
  • Steve Mould
  • Tech Ingredients

Other news (balances liberal bias here on lemmy):

  • Reason TV - could replace with podcast; still love Remy vids though
  • John Stossel

Misc entertainment:

  • Mr. Puzzle
  • Lockpickinglawyer
  • Jerry Rig Everything

If I had one or two solid channels from each category, I could abandon YouTube. But I don't know any of the channels there, and I'm not super excited about looking through a bunch of new channels again, it took years to filter through the trash on YouTube...

[–] [email protected] 5 points 7 months ago (1 children)

So Jason just puts out his videos about 4 days early on Nebula. He's done a small number of Nebula bonus content videos, but not very many. If you like his videos, you might also like CityNerd, Stewart Hicks, City Beautiful, RMTransit, and Hoog which all also cover urbanism.

The HAI crew also operate the Wendover YouTube channel, and under that brand have released a bunch of really good documentaries, including the incredibly moving "Final Years of Majuro". There's also the channel "Extremities" from them, which "brings you the stories of how and why the world's most remote settlements exist". They have their game show, Jet Lag, which is really good, but I think that's on YouTube on a delay; they've recently also announced an upcoming series called "The Getaway", but other than the name and being from that crew, no more is known about it. Completely unrelated to them, there's the channel "neo", which I find satisfies much the same itch as HAI.

For tech news, there's The Friday Checkout, OzTalksHW, and TechAltar, but I watch none of those so can't comment precisely on their content.

No explicit privacy advocacy I'm afraid.

For science, there's Minute Physics, The Science Asylum, and Real Science which are their ones most similar to the ones you listed, but there are also a whole heap that do science from a different angle, like Atlas Pro, which uses real paper atlases as a framing device for talking about world geography; Tibees, who talks through scientific papers; Tier Zoo, who teaches about animals through the lens of video game logic; and Simon Clark, who is primarily focused on climate change through the lens of what science and technology we can use to help prevent it. I still watch and love Stand Up Maths and Steve Mould on YT though.

Not sure I'd ever say Lemmy has a "liberal" bias. More explicitly anti-liberal, tbh. But still, Nebula has TLDR, who do an impeccable job of producing a BBC or ABC-style news show with an explicit goal of leaving their own personal biases at the door and creating a show that avoids bias as much as humanly possible. Their semi-regular "The Editorial" is excellent, with them going over the mistakes they made and issuing corrections. There's also J.J. McCullough, who I don't watch, but have been lead to believe is a right-wing (but not far-right—more the sort of traditional conservative you might have typically expected before the 2000s) creator who seems to cover things in current affairs. And just recently they've added a new channel called Morning Brew, which I'm still trying to get a read on, but seems to be news primarily with a business focus. They've also recently announced a new news division, but we don't know exactly what form that's going to take yet or what sort of content will be coming out of it.

As far a misc entertainment, it's a very personal thing that's hard to give recommendations for. NileRed is listed under the science category, but his videos are often so bizarre that I'd say they're more like light entertainment. There is a huge amount of stuff covering media criticism, some with very serious tones, some much more casual; some looking at the art through specific lenses (there are a couple of queer creators in particular), others who take more of a film production bent, and ones who view it through the lens of pop culture. The film and media categories are probably the strongest part of Nebula. There's edutainment like Extra History. I have never had an interest in professional tennis, but have found CULT TENNIS to be a shockingly interesting channel (one of the ones I discovered through Nebula). A whole bunch of music channels like 12tone, Mary Spender, and Polyphonic; personally, I find them all far too focused on modern music for my tastes as a classical fan. Also technically listed under the "music" category is Tantacrul, though really I'd say many of his videos should be must-watch for anyone doing any sort of software UX design, even though he's specifically focussing on music notation/composition software. LegalEagle is weirdly categorised under "news", which I guess makes sense because a lot of his videos do cover current events, but fundamentally I personally view him as an entertainment channel who talks about the law. If you're a gamer at all, Razbuten is excellent, especially his "...For Someone Who Doesn't Really Play Games" series, where he introduces his wife, who is a non-gamer, to various different genres of games.

Personally, I couldn't ever replace YouTube entirely with Nebula. There's just way too much stuff on YT, and their discovery algorithm has gotten so good. They're really good in some niches, and much weaker in others. Some of the niches they're weak in, they're pretty obviously never going to enter. Live-streaming gaming, for example. But others they're expanding into all the time. When I first joined, they didn't have a single urbanism channel, and now they have most of the big urbanists on YouTube. These days Nebula is big enough that I have to check a couple of times per day to be sure that, if I look at the "latest videos" section of the front page, I don't miss anything entirely. (Though there's always the dedicated latest videos page if I did miss something from the front page.) Latest Videos has been a great way that I've come across entirely new channels and even niches that I wouldn't have thought to be interested in before. It's big, and varied, and growing a lot. I think it'd be hard not for someone to get their money's worth from it.

[–] [email protected] 3 points 7 months ago (1 children)

Lemmy... "liberal"

Yeah, I should've said "leftist" or "socialist."

I don't really fit in with Lemmy politically, I'm just here because Reddit has gone too far with tracking and monetization. I would've been willing to pay for Reddit if they were privacy-friendly, but that ship has sailed.

TLDR

This looks fantastic! I just watched a video on YouTube (about the Belgian far right party) and it was high quality without all the rage baiting. Thanks!

their discovery algorithm has gotten so good

Eh, I found it just devolves into the popular nonsense I try to avoid with clickbait titles and rage bait style. For privacy reasons, I completely disabled watch history and whatnot, and suggestions are now even worse (no surprise there).

I'm trying to completely replace YouTube and Google services generally as a rejection of their data collection (hence the "privacy advocacy" section), so I'm looking for an 80% solution. I can hopefully fill in the rest on Odysee and Rumble (looks like LPL is there), but those are filled with far-right nonsense, and Peertube seems kinda dead, so I'll need a solid base and only look for a handful of replacements.

Anyway, thanks! You've given a lot of great options, so I'll try it out and see if I can finally drop YouTube, at least for subscribed content (YouTube is still king for finding specific music). I don't really care about bonus content, I just want something like YouTube that doesn't have ads, tracking, and clickbait, and I'm willing to pay.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 7 months ago (1 children)

Another platform that I haven't yet signed up for, but probably will before too long, is Dropout. Created by the former head of the YouTube channel CollegeHumor after the old owners collapsed at the hands of a private equity firm, it now hosts a whole range of comedy content, from game shows (Um, Actually is mostly available on YouTube, and is excellent), to sketch comedy (clips from Game Changer and Make Some Noise are available as YT Shorts—I've seen them called a spiritual successor to Who's Line Is It Anyway, especially after Wayne Grady guest starred in an episode), and their D&D show Dimension 20. It's entirely in that "misc entertainment" category, and all from one single studio, but it's shockingly good for that.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 7 months ago

Cool, that also sounds right up my alley. I'll check it out. :)

[–] [email protected] 4 points 7 months ago

Oh, another thing just occurred to me. There are also Nebula-exclusive podcasts. I listen to The Urbanist Agenda, hosted by Jason Slaughter, with regular guests including (but not limited to) the other urbanists on Nebula.

[–] [email protected] 3 points 7 months ago (1 children)

You forgot to mention that at least with the newer videos, the videos cut out all the sponsored sections.

[–] [email protected] 4 points 7 months ago (1 children)

Oh, yeah. I guess I just took that as a given. @[email protected], this is worth knowing too, if you weren't already aware.

(Though with SponsorBlock, you can achieve much the same thing on YouTube, albeit in a more morally grey way.)

[–] [email protected] 3 points 7 months ago (1 children)

Thanks for the heads up. :)

I don't use SponsorBlock (but do use ad-block) because creators need to eat, but it's good to know that nonsense will be gone in Nebula. :)

[–] [email protected] 1 points 7 months ago (1 children)

I actually mostly love Sponsor Block for its non-sponsor things. Stuff like cutting out intro animations, cutting long silences in recorded streams, skipping "interaction reminders" ("don't forget to like and subscribe"), and occasionally jumping straight to the music in music videos.

[–] [email protected] 1 points 7 months ago

I just drop channels that do that nonsense.

I'm okay with a 10-20s sponsor mention at the start or end, but some of them get long (like 1min+) or are right in the middle. Likewise, a quick 3s "like and subscribe" nod at the end is fine, just annoying in the middle.

If a channel is annoying its viewers, I know to avoid it because the content is also likely mediocre. If they truly care about the content, they'll keep the annoying crap to a minimum.

It has served me pretty well so far.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 7 months ago (1 children)

I've never actually used Grayjay. Just heard about it for the first time a few hours ago. To be honest I thought it did support playlists. It sounded like if you sign in, you get access to all your YouTube features like playlists and comments. Shame to see that's not the case. My Watch Later playlist is so essential to my YouTube viewing, I guess I'll stick with Revanced for now.

[–] [email protected] 3 points 7 months ago (1 children)

I mean playlists by a channel, not ones you create. I assume you can get those (Grayjay has playlists), but I don't actually has that feature at all.

I watch some channels with a huge back catalogue, and I'll often want to watch something in a category from a year or two back. I don't know how to efficiently find that on Grayjay, but it works fine in NewPipe.

[–] [email protected] 2 points 7 months ago

Oh I see. Yeah I do use those from time to time. Would be a shame not to have them, for precisely the reason you describe.