The purpose of this post is to examine the history of genetic modification in the Federation, prior to "Strange New Worlds". I've tried to compile various references to genetic engineering, eugenics, cloning, and genetic resequencing within the Federation across all series, with quotes and additional context as needed. All examples are presented in real-world chronological order, to better examine how these ideas have evolved over the history of the franchise.
The first reference to eugenics I could find is in the Original Series episode, "The Conscience of the King". In that episode, they briefly described how Kodos was employing his own theories of eugenics when he enacted the massacre at Tarsus IV:
Spock: Kodos began to separate the colonists. Some would live, be rationed whatever food was left. The remainder would be immediately put to death. Apparently, he had his own theories of eugenics.
McCoy: Unfortunately, he wasn't the first.
Spock: Perhaps not. But he was certainly among the most ruthless; to decide arbitrarily who would survive and who would not, using his own personal standards, and then to implement his decision without mercy. Children watching their parents die. Whole families destroyed. Over four thousand people. They died quickly, without pain, but they died. Relief arrived, but too late to prevent the executions.
The subject comes up again, of course, in "Space Seed", when Khan and his fellow prisoners are discovered:
McCoy: The Eugenics Wars.
Spock: Of course. Your attempt to improve the race through selective breeding.
A later statement from Kirk affirms the root cause of the Eugenics Wars:
Kirk: An improved breed of human. That's what the Eugenics War was all about.
Spock is the first to suggest that there was a fatal flaw in the engineering process:
Pock: In 1993, a group of these young supermen did seize power simultaneously in over forty nations.
Kirk: Well, they were hardly supermen. They were aggressive, arrogant. They began to battle among themselves.
Spock: Because the scientists overlooked one fact. Superior ability breeds superior ambition.
Kirk: Interesting, if true. They created a group of Alexanders, Napoleons.
Khan himself has some thoughts on his own abilities relative to the rest of humanity:
Khan: Captain, although your abilities intrigue me, you are quite honestly inferior. Mentally, physically. In fact, I am surprised how little improvement there has been in human evolution. Oh, there has been technical advancement, but, how little man himself has changed.
Little is said about genetic engineering for quite some time, until we get to The Next Generation's "Unnatural Selection". This one appears to be a bit of an outlier, given what we later learn about genetic enhancement, but it may be possible to reconcile it. When the Enterprise crew first meet Dr. Kingsley of the Darwin Genetic Research Station, she makes the nature of her research seem as innocuous as possible:
Kingsley: Our research here is limited to human genetics. I can assure you we're not dealing with something that got away from us. We believe that we were infected by a supply ship that was here three days ago.
Later, she acknowledges that the children aboard the station are genetically enhanced, with an interesting caveat:
Kingsley: Our ultimate achievement. The oldest is twelve, and all are telekinetic. Watch.
Pulaski: Genetically engineered?
Kingsley: Not engineered, created. Perfect in every way. Their body structure, their musculature, their minds.
I find it very interesting that Kingsley draws this line between "engineering" and "creation" - this distinction seems to hold some relevance to her, but it's not explored in the episode itself. Could Federation law draw a distinction between genetic modification of living individuals and cloning?
This episode also gives us an example of a genetic medical treatment of sorts, when the transporters are modified to filter out the genetic changes Pulaski endured when she transported over to the Darwin station.
Another Next Generation episode, "Up the Long Ladder", reveals some attitudes about cloning, specifically:
Riker: You want to clone us?
Granger: Yes.
Riker: No way, not me.
Granger: How can you possibly be harmed?>
Riker: It's not a question of harm. One William Riker is unique, perhaps even special. But a hundred of him, a thousand of him diminishes me in ways I can't even imagine.
Notably, when Riker and Pulaski are cloned without their knowledge or consent, Riker destroys the clones outright while they are still developing.
The episode also mentions "replicative fading," a process by which errors creep into the chromosomes of clones across successive generations, until the clones are no longer viable.
In Deep Space Nine's "A Man Alone", Odo arrests Ibudan for murdering his own clone in an attempt to frame Odo for murder:
Odo: Killing your own clone is still murder.
Notably, Odo is likely referring to Bajoran law, not Federation law, in this case.
The Next Generation's "Bloodlines" contains an early reference to DNA resequencing, a term which will be used more frequently going forward. It is also another example of flawed genetic manipulation:
Picard: You know as well as I do, Bok, he's not my son. I know what you've done. Miranda Vigo is his mother but I am not his father. You made it appear so because you resequenced his DNA. But your technique was flawed. He developed a neurological disorder. When my ship's Doctor investigated it, she discovered what you had done.
Later, Jason Vigo notes that he is responding well to an unspecified treatment provided by Doctor Crusher, and that the damage caused by the DNA resequencing may be completely reversed.
Federation law regarding genetic enhancements starts to come into focus in Deep Space Nine's "Doctor Bashir, I Presume":
O'Brien: You're not a fraud. I don't care what enhancements your parents may have had done. Genetic recoding can't give you ambition, or a personality, or compassion or any of the things that make a person truly human.
Bashir: Starfleet Medical won't see it that way. DNA resequencing for any reason other than repairing serious birth defects is illegal. Any genetically enhanced human being is barred from serving in Starfleet or practising medicine.
Later, Rear Admiral Bennett makes the case for these laws, echoing the sentiments of Spock in "Space Seed":
Bennett: Two hundred years ago we tried to improve the species through DNA resequencing, and what did we get for our trouble? The Eugenics Wars. For every Julian Bashir that can be created, there's a Khan Singh waiting in the wings. A superhuman whose ambition and thirst for power have been enhanced along with his intellect. The law against genetic engineering provides a firewall against such men and it's my job to keep that firewall intact.
It's interesting that ambition is something specifically cited by O'Brien that cannot be influenced by genetic resequencing, while Bennett says that it can.
In Voyager's "The Raven", the EMH uses genetic resequencing to neutralize Seven of Nine's nanoprobes. Borg nanoprobes are obviously not a birth defect, so it appears that other medical uses of resequencing are considered ethical and legal.
Deep Space Nine's "Statistical Probabilities" contains a number of conversations about the Federations laws surrounding genetic enhancement, and their effects.
Also in this episode, Bashir acknowledges that resequencing methods can be imperfect (perhaps particularly when it is forced to be done "underground"):
There's also a debate about the laws and regulations surrounding resequencing. For the first time, the possibility of a "genetic arms race" is raised - in fact, Odo (seemingly erroneously) claims that this is why the laws were enacted:
In "Tears of the Prophets", there's a brief scene which suggests Bashir has been providing Jadzia Dax with treatment designed to make her DNA more compatible with Worf's:
In "Chrysalis", there is another brief debate on the way the Federation has chosen to treat resequenced individuals:
Bashir has thoughts about his personal experience:
In Voyager's "The Fight", Chakotay reveals that he received genetic treatment before birth. This is not presented as something that should be seen as controversial:
"Lineage" also delves into the medical ethics of genetic resequencing, as Torres wrestles with some complex emotions regarding her pregnancy. First, the Doctor identifies an issue that can be addressed with routine genetic modification:
However, Torres later requests some modifications that the Doctor is unwilling to perform:
Torres brings her wishes to Captain Janeway, who refuses to order the Doctor to perform the procedure. Notably, Janeway does not cite Federation law, and discusses ethics instead:
Torres ends up tampering with the Doctor's program in an attempt to force him to do the procedure, and it does lead to him makng a medical case for it (albeit one based on falsified information):
In "Imperfection", Icheb devises a genetic resequencing technique that will allow him to regulate his Borg implants without a cortical node, which he donates to Seven of Nine.
Enterprise delves into the Eugenics Wars in a number of season four episodes. The series also introduces a new term to describe enhanced individuals: augment. Of course, this series predates the Federation, so all references to the law are referring to Earth law, specifically. from the context, I think it's possible that later Federation law are at least slightly more permissive.
In "Borderland", the merits of genetic engineering are discussed several times. First, Archer has an exchange with Arik Soong:
Later, Phlox reveals that genetic engineering is fairly routine amongst his own people. Despite this, he seems generally supportive of Earth's laws surrounding augmentation:
Soong also tries to play to Archer's emotions:
In "Cold Station 12", it seems Soong's argument got to Archer, although it has not changed his resolve:
In "The Augments", we return to the notion that violent behaviour is inherent to augmented individuals (or, at least, these remnants from the Eugenics Wars):
Later, Archer manages to quote words that Spock won't utter for decades, though it appears Spock had lifted that from someone else without attributing it properly:
Finally, Discovery acknowledges the laws surrounding DNA resequencing in "Choose Your Pain":
Of course, Stamets ends up augmenting himself with Ripper's DNA, which the Federation tolerates out of necessity.
This concludes my historical summary of the Federation's history with genetic modification. Obviously, Strange New Worlds has delved further into this, and I welcome commentary that ties those more recent episodes to this history.
My primary takeaways from this summary are:
The regulations surrounding genetic resequencing stem from Earth laws enacted following the Eugenics Wars. It's possible that those Earth laws were stricter than the later Federation laws, as certain medical interventions appear to have not been permitted, while it seems that they may have been later.
In the Federation, genetic manipulation is permitted when there is a medical need, and possibly to enable cross-species reproduction.
Individuals who have received resequencing are prone to unintended side effects, which the Federation has had limited success in addressing.
Individuals who have received resequencing have also discussed being disrciminated against, both legally in the sense of being barred from certain professions, as well as socially.
Another key takeaway from this that I hadn't considered before:
Augments aren't just banned from Starfleet. They can't become doctors either. Speaking as a Jew my people know firsthand that one of the best ways to create an underclass is to restrict the occupations available to them. Are augments systematically kept out of skilled professions, denied the chance to better themselves and their fellow sapients? Very disturbing possiblity.
The conversations in "Statistical Probabilities" definitely suggest the restrictions extend beyond Starfleet and medicine.
It's also likely that the stigma attached to being augmented could prevent someone from being hired into certain positions, even if there are no formal rules against it.
I want to push back on the conversation between Jack and Bashir in "Statistical Probabilities" a little bit given additional context from Strange New Worlds "Ad Astra per Aspera." I don't think it's fair to say that all augments are treated the same way. It's unlikely I think, that even if Bashir were to have not lied to get into Starfleet he would have been prevented either by law or by policy of doing anything even remotely scientific - including medicine or other gene research.
However, I don't think we can take Jack at his word that he would have been institutionalized in the same manner. If we believe that the genetically modified people we see from the Institute in Deep Space Nine weren't driven mad by their perceived incarceration then we have to believe that side effects of the genetic modification process caused unexpected neurological abnormalities and personality disorders that we see typified by that group.
Dal, for instance, in Prodigy does not fear institutionalization in the Federation, but rather he fears he won't be let into Starfleet. Presumably he may also be precluded from other career choices that he's just not interested in, but I don't think it's fair to say that being an augment is criminal as much as it is laws have created a system whereby modified people, especially modified humans, are treated as second class citizens. This might even extend to people who have DNA sequencing done for legitimate medical reasons like Chakotay. I like to imagine Chakotay and Una and Bashir having similar experiences even though their circumstances were unique. The human willingness to look past reason and into bigotry doesn't go away, but it's focused on the genetically modified.
And it takes decades, centuries even, for the laws to change even a little bit and even longer for the people to accept those changes.
Well, that specific bit comes from "Doctor Bashir, I Presume," not "Statistical Probabilities," and he's talking to O'Brien, so I think we can assume he's not exaggerating...however, O'Brien's response is interesting when you take Strange New Worlds into consideration:
So Bashir could be right, in that he's interpreting the laws as written, but you could also be right, in that it's possible no case has gone before the courts in quite some time, perhaps even since Una's.
Whoa! Good catch. That timeline almost lines up exactly and it's very possible that O'Brien was referring to Una. It could also be that O'Brien is indicating that sentiments have maybe changed somewhat in 100 years, something that we are lead to expect from SNW. And indeed Bashir is allowed to stay in Starfleet without even having to find a technical loophole and Richard's punishment is considered harsh at 2 years. Given the future utopia that we're dealing with and the historical significance of the crime I think what we're seeing is that no one really does this anymore and so it's not really an issue.
I really hate that Prodigy was unrewened because a courtroom episode of Prodigy where Dal gets the right to serve in Starfleet and the Starfleet ban on genetic augments is lifted would be a pretty cool.